Skip to main content

How speculators exploit commodity markets

I use the word "exploit" because it was part of the original title of John Dizard's recent Financial Times article on speculators gaming the commodity markets.

Specifically, the charge put forth by Dizard's article is that locals on the exchange floors have been betting against commodity index funds by taking advantage of their need to roll contracts over in a timely and predictable manner. This, the article shows, costs money for investors in these types of funds. Says Dizard:

Speculators on the floors of commodities exchanges have been called many things, but sensitive, or solicitous of the interests of public investors, are not among them.

So it shouldn't be surprising that one of the ways they have of profiting from the passively investing public is called "date rape". In the pits, physical or electronic, that means betting against the certainty that commodity index investors' positions are rolled in a mechanistic manner every month, in known patterns on particular days. The phenomenon could be called index roll congestion, or some other euphemism, but as we noted, these are not people who worry about your feelings.

Are speculators unfairly squeezing investors, or are they simply acting out their part by exploiting (in the sense of taking advantage) a telegraphed signal from their counterparty?

Read, "How the speculators profit from investors in commodities", and this response letter, and decide.

The next article from FT's Jeremy Grant also falls in the area of "gaming the trade". His recent report, "Flame blame: how traders may distort energy costs", focuses on the idea that traders in the over-the-counter energy derivatives market are manipulating prices for energy through their low-visibility dealings.

In the following excerpt, Grant explains why American utility groups are upset over the influence OTC traders have on energy prices.

"Over-the-counter" markets have become a powerful feature of the way energy is traded globally - anything from petrol and petroleum futures or natural gas and gas futures to more complex derivatives such as energy swaps. Unlike on the New York Mercantile Exchange, the world's biggest market for oil and natural gas, OTC trading is not conducted in a pit where traders shout orders back and forth and the exchange reports their trades to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the US regulator empowered to oversee on-exchange energy futures.

Instead, participants anywhere in the world negotiate specially tailored contracts with each other - linked by a telephone or computer screen connected to a special platform such as the Intercontinental Exchange, which operates a rapidly growing electronic crude oil futures trading business out of London.

Such ventures have become a popular forum for global trading and account for up to 75 per cent of energy trading in the US - larger than the energy derivatives markets on regular exchanges. Traders are investment banks or, increasingly, hedge funds. But - to the alarm of the Iowa utility group and others - OTC markets have been only lightly regulated since their emergence as a force in energy dealings. Regular exchanges such as Nymex are fully regulated.

Groups like the Iowa utilities and the public gas association are increasingly worried that this means the government is virtually blind to how the OTC markets are operating - and that the prices that consumers pay for energy could be artificially inflated by anonymous traders who operate in cyberspace.

These utility groups are hoping for more regulation over the OTC derivatives markets in the hope that "transparency" might be achieved.

Growth in the over-the-counter derivatives market has been staggering. The print edition of this article was accompanied by an interesting little graph showing the growth of OTC derivatives markets in relation to exchange-traded derivatives. If memory serves, the OTC derivatives market surpassed its exchange-listed counterpart in the early 1990s and has far outpaced it since.

Here is a (PDF file) table from the Bank For International Settlements that gives a snapshot of the OTC derivatives market as of June 2006. The notional amount of all contracts for this period was around 369.9 trillion dollars.

Popular posts from this blog

Clean Money - John Rubino: Book review

Clean Money by John Rubino 274 pages. Hoboken, New Jersey John Wiley & Sons. 2009. 1st Edition. The bouyant stock market environment of the past several years is gone, and the financial wreckage of 2008 is still sharp in our minds as a new year starts to unfold. Given the recent across-the-board-declines in global stock markets (and most asset classes) that have left many investors shell-shocked, you might wonder if there is any good reason to consider the merits of a hot new investment theme, such as clean energy. However, we shouldn't be too hasty to write off all future stock investments. After all, the market declines of 2008 may continue into 2009, but they may also leave interesting investment opportunities in their wake. Which brings us to the subject of this review. John Rubino, author and editor of GreenStockInvesting.com , recently released a new book on renewable energy and clean-tech investing entitled, Clean Money: Picking Winners in the Green Tech Boom . In Clean

Slate profiles Victor Niederhoffer

Slate's recent profile of writer/speculator, Vic Niederhoffer has been getting some attention from traders and finance types in recent days. I thought we'd take a look at it here too, to offer up some possible educational value from Vic's experiences with trading and loss. Here's an excerpt from Slate's profile of Victor Niederhoffer : " I've enjoyed getting your e-mails. It sounds like you've thought a lot about being wrong. Well, the reason you contacted me, to call a spade a spade, is that I'm sort of infamous for having made a big, notorious, terrible error not once but twice in my market career. Let's talk about those errors. The first was your investment in the Thai baht, which pretty much wiped you out when the Thai stock market crashed in 1997. I made so many errors there it's pathetic. I made one of my favorite errors: "The mouse with one hole is quickly cornered." That is key. There are certain decisions you make in li

Seth Klarman: Margin of Safety (pdf)

Welcome, readers! Signup for free email updates at the Finance Trends Newsletter . Update: PDF links removed due to DMCA notice. Please see our extensive Klarman book notes below. New visitors, please check the Finance Trends home page for all new posts. Here's something for anyone who has been trying to get a look at Seth Klarman's now famous, and out of print, 1991 investment book, Margin of Safety .  My knowledge of value investing is pretty much limited to what I've read in Ben Graham's The Intelligent Investor (the book which originally popularized the investment concept of a "Margin of Safety"), so check out the wisdom from Seth Klarman and other investing greats in our related posts below. You can also go straight to Ronald Redfield's Margin of Safety book notes .    Related posts: 1. Seth Klarman interviews and Margin of Safety notes     2. Seth Klarman: Lessons from 2008 3. Investing Lessons from Sir John Templeton 4.